Leading in Heels or High Tops: Why Authenticity Wins in Women’s Leadership

There’s a moment—sometimes in your first job, sometimes well into your career—when you realize the rulebook wasn’t written for you.

You walk into a room full of decision-makers. You’ve done the work. You’ve got the numbers. You’ve practiced the pitch. But something shifts. Maybe it’s the way someone glances at your shoes. Maybe it’s the subtle raise of an eyebrow when you speak with emotion. Maybe it’s the quiet suggestion that you should be “a little more polished” or “a bit less intense.”

You weren’t being unprofessional. You just weren’t performing the part they’re used to seeing.

It’s not always loud, this realization. Sometimes it creeps in through backhanded compliments. Sometimes it hits hard after you watch a less-qualified colleague get praised for the same trait you were critiqued for.

And that’s when it clicks: the traditional mold of leadership was never designed with you in mind.

So you’re left with a choice. Do you keep bending to fit into someone else’s version of strong, competent, and acceptable? Or do you build something entirely different—something that feels real?

The many versions of ‘leader’ we never saw growing up

Think back to the leaders we grew up watching—the ones on TV, in movies, in history books. They usually had the same look. Straight-backed. Loud-voiced. Terse. Confident, but always in a specific, sharp-edged way. They didn’t cry. They didn’t admit doubt. They didn’t show softness unless it came with an apology.

Most of us didn’t see ourselves in them. Not really.

So we copied what we thought leadership looked like. We lowered our voices. We adjusted our tone. We avoided being “too much”—too assertive, too emotional, too ambitious. We edited ourselves for rooms that weren’t built to hold us.

And the tricky part? Some of us were praised for it. “She’s so poised.” “You’re not like the others.” “You know how to carry yourself.” But underneath those compliments was a quiet, persistent message: You’re good because you’ve learned to fit in.

It’s no wonder so many women leaders spent years wearing a version of themselves that didn’t quite fit. The suit looked right. The smile looked right. But something underneath was always tight—like we were holding our breath.

We didn’t lack leadership potential. We lacked models of leadership that looked like us, talked like us, moved like us. And when you’ve never seen it, it takes real guts to become it.

The quiet power of being exactly who you are

She showed up in a leather jacket. No blazer. No corporate filter on her voice. She talked straight, laughed loud, and didn’t pause to make anyone more comfortable.

People listened anyway.

Not because she was trying to impress them. But because she didn’t need to.

There’s something magnetic about someone who’s done trying to play a part. You can feel the shift. The room doesn’t tense up around them—it exhales. People stop performing, too. The energy changes when authenticity walks in.

And that’s the thing no one tells you. You don’t have to choose between being respected and being yourself. You don’t have to strip away your quirks, your warmth, your style to gain influence. In fact, people trust you more when you don’t.

Pretending is exhausting. Leading with truth? That gives you stamina.

Leadership isn’t a uniform—it’s a voice

Some wear heels. Some wear high tops. Some wear neither. And none of it says a thing about how well they lead.

We’ve spent too much time confusing appearance with authority. But leadership doesn’t come from wardrobe choices or posture tricks. It shows up in how someone makes decisions. How they carry others through uncertainty. How they own their mistakes without crumbling.

You can speak softly and still hold a room. You can smile often and still mean business. You can wear red lipstick, no makeup, or a bare face and still be taken seriously—if you take yourself seriously first.

What makes people listen isn’t the image you’ve crafted. It’s the steadiness in your words. The way your message stays consistent, even when the audience changes. That’s what sticks.

They don’t follow your shoes. They follow your voice.

The courage it takes to be fully yourself at the top

It sounds simple—just be yourself. But when the stakes are high and the spotlight’s harsh, authenticity can feel like the riskiest move in the room.

You’ll get opinions. Comments on your tone. Your outfit. Your confidence. Your lack of it. You’ll get called too much and not enough—sometimes in the same sentence.

There’s a kind of pressure that comes with being the “only” or the “first.” And it gets heavier when you’re not willing to shrink to make others more comfortable.

But showing up real doesn’t mean showing up perfectly. It means being consistent. Owning your instincts. Admitting what you don’t know without discrediting what you do. That kind of leadership doesn’t always get applause right away—but it sticks with people. It makes them trust you. Not the version of you they hoped for, but the one who actually exists.

And that’s where the real strength lives.

What younger women are watching—and waiting for

They’re paying attention. More than we think.

Not just to the titles or the resumes, but to how we move through rooms. How we speak up—or don’t. How we carry ourselves when we’re praised, and how we respond when we’re picked apart.

They notice when someone apologizes for taking up space. They notice when someone doesn’t.

They’re watching to see if there’s room for them to lead without playing pretend. And they’re not looking for flawless role models. They’re looking for real ones. Women who stumble and keep going. Women who change their minds, who change direction, who don’t hide it.

Every time we choose honesty over performance, we make it a little easier for them to do the same. Every time we stay grounded in who we are, we give them permission to stay grounded too.

That’s not pressure. That’s a quiet kind of power.

It’s not about heels or high tops. It’s about being grounded.

Some days you show up polished. Other days, practical. Some rooms ask you to soften. Others expect you to harden. But none of that matters if you’re not steady inside your own skin.

You can walk in wearing whatever makes you feel most like yourself. That’s not the point. What matters is that you walk in as yourself.

Because real leadership doesn’t wobble when the dress code shifts. It doesn’t disappear when the room gets quiet. It holds steady. It knows what it stands for. It doesn’t ask for permission to belong.

And if you’ve spent years adjusting, editing, performing—maybe this is the moment you stop. Maybe this is the year you lead with both feet planted, voice clear, shoulders relaxed.

Because you don’t need to fit the part. You are the part.

Facebook
Twitter
Email
Print

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Latest News